Monthly Game Talks: July 2015 !

For this Monthly Game Talks I will focus on playing with your spouce/girlfriend. It is often hard to gather together a large group of friends to play a boardgame on a weeknight. However, my wife and I do find time to get together to play two player games from time to time. She prefers spatial-reasoning games like RoboRally, while I savor games where there is a large development effect (as in planting and tending a garden or what some call “snowball” games.

Unfortunately, our favorite games (RoboRally and Puerto Rico as examples) do not play very well with only two players.

pic2500695_md

Thus, I am always on the lookout for more games that can fit the two-player bill. Two player games are often in a class of their own. One problem that immediately jumps out is the problem of a runaway leader. In a multiplayer (3 or more) game, the other players outnumber the leader and can gang up. But in a two-player game, there’s only the losing player.

Unless the game has some sort of artificial catch-up mechanism, it can be a very hard row to hoe in order to catch back up to the leader. If a two player game is sufficiently complex to allow me to enjoy developing my own little empire, the game tends to take two or more hours to play. If one player gains a distinct lead, then the losing player could find themselves sitting through a losing battle for upwards of an hour.

This is not a tantalizing proposition for a fair-weather fan of boardgames (such as my wife), and even though I just love games I don’t find it all that enjoyable either.

pic153238_md

A second problem with many two player games is a lack of options. Many of the “best” two player games are lightweight fillers that only give a few options for the players and do not provide a diverse set of ways to win. One of the things I enjoy most in a game is exploring various paths to victory. In a two-player game against my less competitive wife, I often find enjoyment in trying more obscure strategies, just to see how they pan out. In many 2-player games, there just aren’t that many options.

Currently, I own just a few games that have the variety, depth, and playability that I enjoy and can also be played with only two players.

The first is the Settlers of Catan Card Game. This game is great as players can develop their country in different ways, there are a reasonable number of strategies that can be tried, and it plays in just over an hour or so. Its main drawback lies in the “catch-up” problem. Since it is a resource production based game, a player who falls behind early in resource production will often remain behind the whole game with no hope of catching up.

In fact, I have a friend who feels the determining factor for the win will always go to the player who gets the most towns built. (There are an odd number of additional settlements so if they are all built, one player will always have and extra compared to their opponent.)

pic911301_md

A second, less frequently played, game is San Juan. As a fan of Puerto Rico, San Juan hits the right spot for me, giving me lots of options and a few ways to win, while remaining a two player game. San Juan can also have disproportionate production issues, but I find it to be less frequent than in the Settlers of Catan Card Game. The newest game to add to my two-player lineup is Caylus. I was very pleasantly surprised at how well Caylus holds up to a two player situation. There are still many paths to victory points, and lots of fun little combinations to consider, but the game plays just fine with only two players. Sure, some things become a bit more predictable, but there are even some strategies that can be implemented in a two-player game that just don’t work well in a multiplayer game. In one game I decided to try to build buildings as much as possible, just to see what would happen. I managed to win, but only because I pushed the provost out ahead as fast as I could and my glut of buildings precluded my wife from being able to build (and use) the necessary buildings to build any of the blue mega-point buildings. While this is not an uncommon strategy in a multiplayer game, in a two-player game it can become slightly more extreme, since I had to build much harder in order to prevent my wife from getting the buildings she wanted.

pic1966037_md

In all, I’m pleased with the games I’ve found so far that match my favorite style. (I admit I now need to work on more spatial logic games to appeal to my wife’s sensibilities, I have a few possibilities that I plan to look into – Ricochet Robot for one…) I’m curious what other people have found for middleweight to heavyweight games that work well with two players. Twilight Struggle, Memior ’44, and other Euro-wargames are all possibilities, but while there are many good two-player wargames; I think the entire genre is one that has less possibilities for playing with my spouse.

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑

sdubblog.wordpress.com/

paint more minis

figurementors

Get inspired along your journey to becoming an artist.

Octopus Workshop

Une figurine, un pinceau... LA VIE !

Meeples & Miniatures

Where Miniature Wargames & Strategy Boardgames collide

In Third Person

A personal look into video games, board games and other nerdy pursuits. www.inthirdperson.com.

Ludeme

Game Systems - Review - Design

Meeple Like Us

Board Games Reviews and Accessibility Teardowns

Tartenpionne

Amusez-vous bien!

La Ligue des Jeuxsticiers

Club de jeux et jeux de rôle à Bruxelles (Woluwe-St-Lambert et Auderghem).

Oakleaf Games

Board Games by Nat Levan

Formal Ferret Games

Gil Hova designs, publishes, and plays board games

Heavy Cardboard

A podcast dedicated to the enjoyment of heavy board games.

quirkworthy.wordpress.com/

A game designer's view of gaming

Scrawlings of a Mad Man

Ramblings and Ravings

Jeux Sais Pas Peindre

Le prépeint c'est bien !

Tim's Board​games

Writing about games

La Tour à Dés

Tout sur les jeux de société. Everything about boardgames.

Go Play Listen

A board and card game guide, review & design blog with added extras

TGIK Games Blog

Game Design, Design Process and Review

Boardgamecafe.net

The Leading Boardgame Community for Malaysia

GeekMate

Play & Replay

40k Conquest, le Blog

Pour tout savoir sur la strategie à adopter sur Traxis !

Whose Turn Is It Anyway?

A discussion podcast about board games, designing board games, and the board game community.

My Little Poppies

suddenly, unexpectedly, homeschooling.

Ma Vraie Vie de MAF

Mère Au Foyer... mais pas que...

Hip mums à Bruxelles

Bons plans et chouettes adresses pour femmes curieuses et mamans dynamiques

Japan Boardgames

Let's talk about Japanese games, shall we?

S Marks The Spots

Discover foodie and fun spots in Brussels, London, Paris and beyond!

whyiamnotskinny

sharing food experiences

Nick Bentley Games

perfectly simple board games

2onBoard

A 2-player tabletop gaming resource

Across the Board Games

Reviews, Kickstarter Updates, Community Discussion

Cartazimut 2017 * XIII

Convention montoise sur les jeux de cartes et jeux de société .

As a Board Gamer

Board Game reviews / Bordspel recensies

Life, and Other Co-op Adventures

Stuff I'm learning about life in general and making games in particular.

play without fear

on game design and play

Hall of Beorn

A Lord of the Rings LCG Blog

Ironwatch Magazine

This Mantic Fan-Produced Magazine!

The Tao of Gaming

Boardgames and lesser pursuits

dominionstrategy.wordpress.com/

Cards, Combos, and Counters

Painted Wooden Cubes

Board Gaming with soul.

Thoughts From The Gameroom

The ramblings of a Euro-gamer from South Dakota

%d bloggers like this: